Restaurant - Bar - Café

Shelter Island, New York

Monday - Thursday 12pm - 8pm

Friday - Saturday 12pm - 9pm

Sunday - 11am - 9pm


The Flying Goat Restaurant is located at historic Shelter Island Country Club. 2017 will mark 115 years of continuous operation of the club which is recognized on the National Register of Historic Places. The club was originally founded in 1901 as a private golf club for Shelter Island Heights property owners who came to spend their summers on Shelter Island. The club became public in 1942 and has been enjoyed by generations of locals and visitors.

Come enjoy this beautiful, and historic place with us. Join us for a meal or sip a cool drink while taking in the panoramic views from one of the highest points on Shelter Island. Each Monday, dinner will be served family style, and our special lobster dinner will be served every Thursday.

Flying Goat Restaurant Shelter Island About Image 1 Flying Goat Restaurant Shelter Island About Image 2


26 Sunnyside Drive

Shelter Island Heights

New York 11965



We are closed for the season.

We will reopen April 2019

To book an event call: